[Sonar] Official Fleet Rules

[J.R.]

My point last year and again this year will be that your point #3 is not
consistent with the Racing Rules of Sailing ... because that would exclude
boats from competing for boat of the year in that race .... this is
specifically prohibited in the RRS......  so the *club* (WYC) needs to
address BOTY scoring if boats are excluded from participation in part of
BOTY.

 "3. On days when the Star of the North regatta takes place there is no
Sonar race scored.  Or should we just say that during any regatta that the
fleet officially participates in there is no Sonar scoring for the
WYC series race on the same day?"

So we can exclude a race or a number of races from being counted for the
whole sonar fleet but the race would still need to held and scored for
anyone wishing to participate due to BOTY scoring / series.


JR



On Fri, Jan 15, 2010 at 8:46 PM, Mark Kochendorfer <markoch at gmail.com>wrote:

> wyc.org has a page now to put special fleet rules.  Take a look at the
> link at wyc.org/racing & results/Official special fleet rules.
>
> To avoid future misunderstandings we should formalize what our rules are
> and post them on the web site.
>
> I don't think we need to get all legalistic, but just put down what our
> intent is in language that is as clear as we can make it.
>
> Maybe someone with more experience with this could take a shot at writing
> our rules down and we could approve them sometime before May.   I thought of
> a few things we may wish to include (see below).  Let me know if you wish to
> draw up a set of fleet rules or if you have any that we need to include.
>
> 1. We are governed by the Official Sonar Class rules - except that any WYC
> member may steer subject to wyc rules not just class members.  Are there
> other exceptions to the official class rules?
>
> 2. On the day of the Lonar race there is no Sonar race scored in the Big
> Island Series.  See the fleet 5 site for Lonar date and NOR.
>
> 3. On days when the Star of the North regatta takes place there is no Sonar
> race scored.  Or should we just say that during any regatta that the fleet
> officially participates in there is no Sonar scoring for the WYC series race
> on the same day?
>
> 4. During the Fleet sponsored team racing events?  I am not suggesting
> this, just asking.
>
> 5. No points given when you miss a WYC race to attend an official Sonar
> sanctioned class race
> OR
> A boat may be awarded the average of its points scored in that series, for
> one (missed) race per series, if a boat and its crew have traveled to race
> in a class-sanctioned event. As such, the average of its points scored shall
> be rounded to the nearest whole number (with .5 being rounded up to 1.0).
>
> I don't care either way, but we can discuss it.  I noticed that they only
> award points if the boat and crew travel.  Our boats seem to travel very
> infrequently.
>
> --
> Mark
>
> _______________________________________________
> Sonar mailing list
> Sonar at lists.wyc.org
> http://lists.wyc.org/mailman/listinfo/sonar
>
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://lists.wyc.org/pipermail/sonar/attachments/20100116/4d985f1d/attachment.htm